I had no idea what it was called, but the mirror I passed up that was gone when I went back was a Venetian Mirror. I've seen these for hundreds of dollars and having passed one up for only $80, I figured I'd never find it in my price range again. After looking around online, I found this one that is very similar to the one I passed up.
It was a little more than the original one, but I bought it immediately. Its beautiful and even if it doesn't work over my bed, I'll use it somewhere else (maybe above my fireplace?). I just hope it arrives in one piece!